| Platinum | Joe's Inn the Fan |
| Gold | Padow's Ham & Deli |
| Silver | The Daily Kitchen & Bar |
| Bronze | The Answer Brewpub |
| Top Pick | Annie Ruth's Wine and Bistro |
| Top Pick | Burger Bach |
| Top Pick | Kreggers |
| Top Pick | Liberty Public House |
| Top Pick | Secret Sandwich Society |
| Top Pick | WPA Bakery |