| Platinum | Padow's Ham & Deli |
| Gold | Secret Sandwich Society |
| Silver | Polpetti |
| Bronze | Jason's Deli |
| Bronze | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Top Pick | Charlotte's Southern Deli & Tapas |
| Top Pick | Chimbo Sandwich Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Liberty Public House |
| Top Pick | Mary Angela's Pizzeria |